Darth Vader, Mona Lisa, and The Golden Mean :: Margins of error

I made this video earlier

Which shows that the Golden Mean is used even more extensively in Darth Vader’s helmet design than Mona herself, who is famous for it.

Darth Vader Golden Mean
Mona Lisa Golden Mean

The point (that I never get to in the video) behind all this, is not that Darth Vader is related to Mona Lisa… but that there is a margin of error in artistic applications of the golden mean. It’s not big… I’d say (at a guess) it’s around 3%. In a later post, I’ll collect a medium-ish sample-size of examples and figure out exactly what it is.

A couple of things alerted me to this… one is the nautilus shell which is always being used as an example…

Now that ain’t the golden mean. The exact ratio is closer to 290.5/219.4 = 1.324 (18% wrong)… which is miles out. Now… the measurements on Darth or Mona’s faces are nowhere near as inacurate as that – but they’re still not 100%… As I say, I’m guessing they’re about 3%. I think people operate a confirmation-bias when it comes to golden-mean stuff, so the nautilus (and others) get cited as examples… when really, they’re quite a long way off.

The other thing that makes me suspect that there’s a margin of error is the recent fuss about the iCloud logo conforming to the golden mean

They say 1.6… but 1.6 isn’t the golden mean (it’s 1.1% out)… 1.618 is closer…

So I got an official version of the iCloud logo…

The RHS circle measurements are 232.7 / 194.2 = 1.2 —–> 25%
The LHS circle measurements are 194.2 / 114.3 = 1.7 —–> 5%

Which is miles out.

Now to be fair to whoever originally blogged about this… the logo they used was different

The RHS circle measurements are 278.0 / 172.2 = 1.614 —–> 0.25%
The LHS circle measurements are 188.2 / 117.2 = 1.605 —–> 0.8%

Which is pretty close to be honest. Apple’s designers obviously went “oh noes, we’ve been rumbled. Change it, quick”.

I’m guessing that the average margin of error in oft-cited examples of golden-mean-dom is about 3% though… so to all intents and purposes, the golden ratio is between 1.67 and 1.57

Which isn’t that much… the middle one is 1.618.

Recent Posts

Wake me up when it’s 2020

Okay, it's 2020 now I guess. [br]I've been making Golden Mean Calipers for about 10 years now. [br]In 2019 I wrote 2 blog posts... that's not enough to achieve the various purposes of writing blog posts, among which are: [br]- to learn what you think [br]- to show people you're still alive [br]- to show google (et al) you're still…
click here for more.

Golden Mean Caliper Comparison Chart

I thought it might be useful for people to be able to compare all the calipers on the one page, so I made a comparison chart. CaliperDescriptionSmallest measurementLargest measurementPrice (USD)Most often used by Small Calipers 120mm or 4.5" high - smallest of the 3-armed calipers 9.5mm or .37" 189mm or 7.5" $35 Beauticians Artists working with detail, or smaller pieces…
click here for more.

Demo of Golden Ratio in Artistic Composition (fairly disorganised)

Over the years, I've built up a collection of Golden Ratio Calipers... and I decided it might be quite useful for people if I made a video comparing them. Some of them are really good - some terrible. So I set up my camera... and found that my video-space looked a bit bare... needed a painting. So I decided to…
click here for more.

Why The Golden Ratio Works For Flowers

Fairly amazing video going into the maths of why flowers (and pine-cones, relative leaf positions etc) are so often based fibonacci numbers. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sj8Sg8qnjOg And it's fairly amazing because I actually understood it. It's been a loooong time since I tangled with quadratic equations, but (on the 2nd watch) this did actually make sense to me. I always thought that with…
click here for more.

Limited Run : Neon Colour Range

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zoPqpqB6er0 I was tinkering with these colours a while back... and then someone with exceptional taste and style made a big order for a whole range of coloured ones... and every one was all "ooh!!!" So I made some for the local art gallery - and they all sold as well. So I made enquiries about getting a lot more…
click here for more.

New Product Videos

I'm putting together a series of product videos... one for each of the 10 or so different calipers that I make. [br]They will all look kindof the same... they're mainly for embedding in shop pages and so on. Because they'll all look kindof the same, I've made a separate youtube channel so subscribers don't lose their minds with boredom. https://youtu.be/qvXxBQCkF30…
click here for more.
Select your currency
EUR Euro